MasonBase

Evidence

The Evidence

MasonBase's operational engine was benchmarked function-by-function against six named products — LodgeMaster, The Working Tools, the official UGLE Portal (Hermes/Adelphi), Masonic Lodge Secretary (US), Grand View Software (US), and Amity — 51 functions scored across nine areas of lodge operation. One framing point matters: this benchmark was run against the Weybridge engine, which is in daily use at Weybridge Lodge and is being brought onto the multi-tenant MasonBase platform in stages. It's the evidence base MasonBase is built from, not a claim that every function below is available to every unit or order today.

Verdict breakdown (51 functions)

VerdictFunctions% of 51
Ahead — no competitor documents it, or ours is clearly deeper2549%
Equal — comparable depth1733%
Mixed — different shape, each leads in places24%
Behind — a competitor documents more than we have built12%
Check — possible gap, to be verified before we claim parity12%
Not live yet — built, but gated behind a decision24%
Not relevant — outside a single unit's needs36%

Documented functional coverage, by product

Counting only what each product's own documentation or marketing describes.

ProductFunctions documented, out of 51
MasonBase (Weybridge engine)46
LodgeMaster25
The Working Tools23
Masonic Lodge Secretary (US)11
UGLE Portal (Hermes/Adelphi)9
Amity (app)9
Grand View Software (US)8

Area by area

AreaFunctionsAheadEqual-or-MixedWatch listStandout
Membership & records413—Installation Return auto-fills from live officer records. Live KPI dashboard from member records: growth, age distribution, rolling 12-month movement, UGLE Portal registration follow-up, referral sources, candidate pipeline, disengagement risk and a one-click visiting officer report. The Working Tools' documentation does not mention KPI dashboards or visiting officer reporting
Officers & oversight42118-year officer progression forecasting and succession-risk flagging, plus access that follows the office, with an audit trail and offices-held history. Forecasting is not documented elsewhere (The Working Tools tracks Masonic careers). Officers and succession health on the KPI dashboard, with critical roles flagged at risk
Education & ritual33——Member development record with a stage-by-stage mentoring checklist, ritual learning tracked part by part (learned, assessed, rehearsed, delivered in lodge), private preceptor notes, LOI register and ritual media library. No direct equivalent documented by any competitor (The Working Tools has candidate and careers tracking)
Meetings & summons8431Summons builder with visitor distribution and full response tracking. Minutes and committee agendas can be generated from a meeting transcript, with sections, tracked action items, draft and approved statuses and the source transcript kept alongside; The Working Tools and Masonic Lodge Secretary advertise minutes but do not document transcript-based generation or action tracking. Returns and certificates (Form P, LP&A5, clearance letters, Installation and Provincial returns) are completed into the official forms. Ceremony planner and floor work still to be verified
Dining & bookings743—Card/bank/cash payment at booking with waitlist auto-promotion and conditional refund
Finance12732Full double-entry accounts with drill-down from the balance sheet and trial balance to the source transactions, event accounts for Ladies' Festivals and gala dinners, budgeting and a membership breakeven calculator. Bank statement import with suggested matches that post nothing until confirmed, and a reconciliation report; no competitor documents bank-statement matching (LodgeMaster reconciles payment platforms such as Stripe, PayPal and SumUp). Enforced segregation of duties (read-only auditors, joint unlock approval), period locking and a full year-end close are governance controls no competitor documents. The Working Tools documents a treasurer's cash book, billing and expense tracking
Pastoral3—3—Proactive daily Almoner alert, auto-resolved to whoever holds the office, plus a widows & dependants register with contact log, gifts tracked by funding source and reporting for the Almoner's report to the lodge. Comparable in depth with The Working Tools, which documents welfare events, anniversary reminders, consent-dated contacts and a Welfare Report
Communications & content44——Weybridge's full public website, SEO and heritage archive; LodgeMaster has only a basic theme. New units receive a standard template with About, Bookings and Contact pages. A secure document repository by category, shown according to the member's degree, and newsletters recorded with recipients; not documented by The Working Tools
Platform3—3—Magic-link authentication, row-level security and verified weekly backups across every core table at Weybridge; the backup routine is to be replicated on the multi-tenant platform

Added since the benchmark (not yet scored)

Built at Weybridge since the benchmark was run; these will be scored at the next benchmark:

  • Widows & dependants welfare register: records, contact log with overdue check-in reminders, gifts by funding source, Almoner reporting
  • Attendance-based check-in nudges on the welfare board
  • Installation and Provincial returns completed into the official forms
  • Year-end accounts distributed to members by secure link
  • Dietary needs held as private health data
  • Bulk member import with safe re-runs

Where we're honest about gaps

Four items remain genuinely open:

  • Secretary / officer handover tools — Behind. The Working Tools advertises dedicated handover tools. Our access follows whoever holds an office automatically, appointment changes are audited, offices held are kept as history and welfare records carry over to the next Almoner, but no formal handover pack or checklist exists yet.
  • Online dues collection and subscription billing — built, but not yet live: proration, monthly billing and an under-25 discount all exist in sandbox, gated behind committee sign-off rather than a technical gap.
  • Ceremony planner and floor work — to be verified. LodgeMaster and The Working Tools document role assignment per meeting; ours has candidate ceremony blocks in the summons and an officer roll, but we have not confirmed parity.
  • Availability to new units — most functions are live at Weybridge and are being brought onto the multi-tenant platform in stages. The public site, joining enquiries and unit websites are live now.

Methodology & caveats

  • LodgeMaster was assessed from its own published manual, not hands-on use of the live product.
  • The Working Tools, Masonic Lodge Secretary, Grand View and Amity were assessed from public marketing pages, reviews and app-store listings — their documented depth, not their verified depth.
  • The UGLE Portal is the official membership record system, not a lodge-operations tool, included for context rather than as a direct competitor.
  • The Working Tools was reviewed in more detail in October 2026 from its features and Almoner pages; the notes above reflect that review.
  • The benchmark was re-scored on 6 October 2026 against the Weybridge portal as it now stands: minutes generation (moved to Ahead: transcript-based generation and action tracking are not documented by competitors), the balance sheet and membership breakeven calculator are live, bank reconciliation was renamed bank statement reconciliation and moved to Ahead because no competitor documents bank-statement import and matching, and the life events engine moved from Ahead to Equal after The Working Tools' welfare features were reviewed.
  • Where a competitor's documentation is silent on a function, that function is marked "not documented," never "confirmed absent."
  • Features described from the Weybridge portal are checked against competitor documentation as it is published; where a competitor's public listing is silent on a function, we say so rather than claim it is absent.
Request information